Buying an injection molding machine is a significant capital commitment. The machines are expensive, the tooling costs more, and the decision to add capacity (or shift work in-house from a contract molder) deserves a real analysis. Here's how we walk customers through the ROI math — with financing costs included.
The Scenario
Let's use a real-world example. You're currently sending 500,000 parts per year to a contract molder at $0.85 per part. You've been quoted $185,000 for a used 200-ton injection molding machine that can comfortably run this production.
Current Cost: Contract Molding
- Annual parts: 500,000
- Cost per part: $0.85
- Annual spend: $425,000
In-House Cost: Machine + Operating
First, figure out what it costs to run the machine in-house:
- Machine financing: $185,000 at 7.5% over 60 months = $3,716/month ($44,592/year)
- Material cost: At $0.22/part (resin) × 500,000 = $110,000/year
- Labor: Operator at $55,000/year (assumes one operator running multiple machines)
- Utilities: ~$8,000/year (200-ton press, 8 hours/day)
- Maintenance: ~$6,000/year (budget 3% of machine value)
- Total annual in-house cost: ~$223,592
The Savings
- Contract molding cost: $425,000
- In-house cost: $223,592
- Annual savings: $201,408
Return on Investment
- Total machine cost (financed): $185,000
- Annual savings: $201,408
- Simple payback: under 11 months
That's before accounting for Section 179 tax savings. At a 28% effective tax rate, the Section 179 deduction on $185,000 is worth $51,800 in year-one tax savings. Add that back and your economic payback is closer to 5–6 months.
The Financing Effect
Notice that financing actually improves the ROI analysis in some ways. Instead of deploying $185,000 in cash (or waiting until you have that cash), you put $18,500 down and start capturing savings immediately. The $3,716/month financing cost is substantially less than the $35,416/month you're currently paying the contract molder.
Your first payment is made with money you're already spending — you're just redirecting it. That's what good equipment financing looks like.
What the Analysis Misses
The above is simplified. Real-world factors that change the numbers:
- Tooling costs: If you need new molds, add those to your investment. Molds can range from $5,000 for simple tools to $50,000+ for complex multi-cavity tools.
- Facility costs: Does your building have the power, footprint, and crane capacity for a 200-ton press? If not, factor in facility upgrades.
- Quality control: Contract molders absorb quality risk. In-house production means your QC team handles rejects.
- Volume flexibility: Contract molders scale with demand. A machine you own has fixed costs regardless of volume.
The financial case for in-house injection molding is typically strongest when you have consistent, predictable volume and the contract molder relationship is based on cost rather than unique capabilities.
Getting Your Own Numbers
Every situation is different. If you'd like to run through the ROI analysis on your specific parts and machine quote, call us. We've done this analysis hundreds of times and can often help identify structuring options (longer terms, Section 179 timing, etc.) that improve the picture even further.
