Quick Turn Financial
Financing 1015 min read

CNC Financing vs. Leasing: What's Right for Your Shop?

February 2025

When a shop owner calls asking about financing a new CNC machine, one of the first questions we ask is: do you want to own the equipment at the end? For almost every manufacturer the answer is yes — and that shapes how the deal should be structured. Getting it wrong costs money.

The Core Difference

A loan (equipment finance agreement) is straightforward: you borrow money, make monthly payments, and own the machine outright when the loan is paid off. The equipment shows up on your balance sheet as an asset.

A lease is different. You're essentially renting the equipment for a fixed term. At the end, you have options depending on the lease type — return it, buy it at fair market value, or buy it for $1 (a “$1 buyout” lease, which functions more like a loan).

Tax Treatment

This is where it gets nuanced:

  • Loans: You own the equipment, so you can take Section 179 deduction and bonus depreciation on the full purchase price. For most manufacturing shops in a profitable year, this is the preferred approach.
  • Operating leases: Lease payments are fully deductible as an operating expense. You don't get the lump-sum Section 179 deduction, but your monthly payments come off the top of revenue before you calculate taxable income.
  • $1 buyout leases: Treated like a loan by the IRS. Section 179 applies.

For a shop in a profitable year looking to reduce its tax burden, owning the equipment and taking Section 179 typically wins — which is why it's what most of our customers choose.

Balance Sheet Impact

Loans add both an asset (the equipment) and a liability (the loan balance) to your balance sheet. Leasing used to be a way to keep that debt off the balance sheet, but under current lease accounting rules (ASC 842), most leases longer than 12 months now show up on the balance sheet too. The old off-balance-sheet advantage has largely disappeared.

End-of-Term Ownership

  • Loan: You own the machine. Full stop.
  • $1 buyout lease: You own the machine for $1 at end of term.
  • FMV (fair market value) lease: You can buy the machine at its fair market value, return it, or upgrade to new equipment. Good for technology that may become obsolete.
  • 10% purchase option: You buy the machine at 10% of original cost. A middle ground between FMV and $1 buyout.

CNC machines hold value well and stay productive for 15–20+ years when maintained. For most shops, ownership at the end is the right call — which means a loan or a $1 buyout lease.

Which Should You Choose?

Choose a standard loan or equipment finance agreement (EFA) if: You want to own the equipment, your shop is profitable and you want the Section 179 benefit, and you plan to keep the machine long-term. That describes the large majority of our customers.

Choose a $1 buyout lease if: Same as above, but your lender packages it as a lease for administrative reasons — functionally identical to a loan.

What about an FMV lease? Traditional fair market value leases are far less common in manufacturing than loans and $1 buyout leases. They can fit if you truly plan to return or upgrade the equipment within a few years — but CNC machines hold their value and stay productive for decades, so most shops are better off owning.

When you call Quick Turn, we'll walk through your options with real numbers for your specific situation. The right answer depends on your tax position, cash flow, and what you plan to do with the equipment in five years.

Have Questions About Your Deal?

Call Bob Daly's team directly — no call centers, no waiting.